Next Motherwell Manager Odds - Neilson New Favourite to Replace Wimmer
Searching for the latest next Motherwell manager odds?
Following the unexpected departure of Michael Wimmer, betting sites have launched markets on who’s set to take over in the Fir Park dugout.
Ex-Hearts and Dundee United boss Robbie Neilson currently heads the betting, but he's not the only name being linked with the Steelmen.
Here’s a full rundown of the leading contenders and how the betting is shaping up.
Next Motherwell Manager Odds
Robbie Neilson heads the football betting odds to become the next Motherwell manager following Michael Wimmer's exit.
As Motherwell steps up their search for a new manager at Fir Park, several familiar names have surfaced as strong candidates for the role.
| Candidate | Odds (Next Motherwell Manager) |
|---|---|
| Robbie Neilson | 2/1 |
| Tony Docherty | 4/1 |
| Scott Brown | 6/1 |
| Temur Ketsbaia | 7/1 |
| Steven Naismith | 8/1 |
Odds available with McBookie - Updated, Wednesday, May 28th, 10:30am
Robbie Neilson
Robbie Neilson is one of the most seasoned candidates, boasting an extensive track record in Scottish football.
The 44-year-old is currently out of work following a short stint with USL Championship side Tampa Bay Rowdies, whom he left in April 2025.
Before that, Neilson managed Hearts and Dundee United, achieving three promotions from the Scottish Championship - twice with Hearts and once with United. He also led Hearts to a third-place finish in the Premiership in 2016, guiding them to the Scottish Cup final in 2020.
Known for his structured style and strong leadership, Neilson’s domestic experience and proven track record make him a realistic and credible option for the Fir Park role.
However, he is also prominent in the next Dundee manager odds.
Tony Docherty
Tony Docherty has emerged as one of the favourites for the vacant Motherwell managerial position following his departure from Dundee.
Despite guiding the Dees to a top-six finish in the 2023–24 season, Docherty was relieved of his duties after the club finished 10th in the 2024–25 campaign, narrowly avoiding a relegation play-off.
His extensive experience in Scottish football, including a long-standing assistant role under Derek McInnes at clubs like Aberdeen and Kilmarnock, adds to his credentials.
Given Motherwell's search for a manager with proven top-tier experience, Docherty's recent tenure at Dundee positions him as a leading contender for the Fir Park role.
Scott Brown
Scott Brown has quickly made a name for himself in management and could be a natural fit for Motherwell as they seek a long-term leader with ambition and presence.
Currently managing Ayr United, Brown led the Honest Men to a Scottish Premiership play-off spot in 2024-25, only to fall short against Partick Thistle.
The former Celtic captain is highly respected in the game and has shown a clear desire to develop as a manager. Still early in his coaching journey, Brown combines the drive of a newcomer with the authority of a decorated playing career.
With Motherwell offering a stable platform in the Premiership, it could be the ideal next step for one of Scottish football’s rising managerial talents.
Temur Ketsbaia
Temur Ketsbaia was linked with the Motherwell job after Stuart Kettlewell’s resignation in January, and the 57-year-old Georgian has re-emerged as a contender to take the reins at Fir Park.
Renowned for his passionate playing style during his time at Newcastle United and Dundee, he has an extensive managerial CV, including roles with the national teams of Georgia and Cyprus, as well as with clubs including Olympiacos, AEK Athens, and Anorthosis Famagusta.
After departing his role with Cyprus in September 2024, Ketsbaia expressed a desire to manage in a major European league and reportedly impressed Motherwell's board during the selection process in January.
Steven Naismith
Steven Naismith is another realistic candidate for the Fir Park job, having previously managed at the top level in Scotland.
The 38-year-old was last in charge of Hearts, where he initially found success, guiding the club to European qualification with a fourth-place finish in the 2022-23 season. Despite a strong start, his tenure ended in September 2024 following a dip in form.
A former Scotland international and ex-Everton player, Naismith also served as a coach in Steve Clarke’s national team setup, gaining valuable experience at international level.
Still viewed as a manager with high potential, Motherwell could provide the ideal environment for Naismith to rebuild and establish himself in the Scottish Premiership.
Scottish Premiership on Free Bets
Be sure to check back regularly as we cover all things Scottish Premiership betting in detail.
From managerial moves like this to breaking news, fresh odds, and weekly Scottish football tips from Kai Watson, we’ve got every angle covered
FAQs
Who is favourite to be the next Motherwell manager?
When will Motherwell announce their new manager?
What are the latest Motherwell manager odds?
