Next Celtic Manager Odds: Martin O'Neill Favourite to Replace Wilfried Nancy
Celtic are on the lookout for yet another new manager after parting company with Wilfried Nancy, and betting sites have wasted no time in offering next Celtic manager odds as speculation gathers pace around who could take charge at Celtic Park.
Below, the Free Bets team breaks down the leading names in the market, weighing up their form, experience and fit for the role as the Hoops aim to get their title challenge back on track.
Next Celtic Manager Odds
After just eight matches in charge, Wilfried Nancy has left Celtic, with the Glasgow club once again searching for a new manager to take the reins.
Below, we take a closer look at the names at the top of the next Celtic manager odds list.
| Candidate | Next Celtic Manager Odds |
| Martin O'Neill | 11/8 |
| Shaun Maloney | 7/4 |
| Ange Postecoglou | 7/2 |
| Robbie Keane | 14/1 |
| Gary O'Neill | 14/1 |
Martin O'Neill
Martin O'Neill is firmly in the mix in the betting to return to Celtic Park, and it's easy to see why.
Now 73, he remains one of the most successful managers in the club's modern history, having delivered three league titles and guided Celtic to the UEFA Cup final during his iconic spell between 2000 and 2005.
More recently, O'Neill answered the club's call once again in late 2025, stepping in as interim boss and steadying the ship with seven wins from eight matches following the departure of Brendan Rodgers.
That short stint reignited his bond with the support and underlined his ability to command instant authority.
From a betting perspective, O'Neill heads the next Celtic manager odds list. His deep connection with the club, proven track record and calm leadership all appeal to punters.
The big question is whether Celtic's hierarchy opt for experience or look to a younger, long-term project, but sentiment and substance keep O'Neill firmly on the shortlist.
Shaun Maloney
Shaun Maloney has quickly emerged as another market leader in the next Celtic manager betting.
A hugely popular former player with over 200 appearances for the club, Maloney returned to Celtic in 2025 as a development coach and was closely involved during the interim period with Martin O'Neill, giving him first-hand knowledge of the current squad and club structure.
At 42, Maloney fits the profile of a modern, progressive coach and has expanded his experience through roles with Belgium's national team setup, working alongside elite-level players.
While his managerial CV is still developing, spells at Hibs and Wigan have shown resilience, particularly during difficult circumstances.
Bookmakers clearly expect Celtic to consider continuity and club DNA, and Maloney's blend of familiarity and youth make him a standout option.
Ange Postecoglou
Ange Postecoglou remains a hugely popular figure among Celtic supporters after a trophy-laden first spell at the club.
The Australian delivered five domestic honours between 2021 and 2023, including a Premiership and League Cup double in his debut season, followed by a historic treble, all while implementing his high-tempo, attacking "Angeball" style.
He left for Tottenham in 2023, where he enjoyed early success with a Europa League triumph before a brief and ultimately unsuccessful spell at Nottingham Forest.
Now available, talk of a sensational return to Celtic Park is gathering momentum. Given his strong connection to the club, clear footballing identity and the enduring backing of the Celtic support, Postecoglou would be a standout candidate to replace Nancy.
A reunion would offer familiarity, belief and renewed optimism - provided Ange is open to another spell in the east end of Glasgow.
Robbie Keane
Robbie Keane is another familiar name with strong Celtic connections, being linked with the vacancy following Wilfried Nancy's departure.
The former Republic of Ireland striker remains a popular figure among the Celtic Park support after a hugely successful loan spell in 2010, scoring 16 goals in 19 appearances and leaving a lasting impression.
Since hanging up his boots, Keane has made an impressive start to his managerial career abroad, winning league titles with Maccabi Tel Aviv and later Ferencváros, where he again delivered domestic success in 2025.
Those achievements suggest Keane knows how to manage expectation, handle pressure and maximise the potential of strong squads - all key traits for any Celtic boss.
His elite playing pedigree, winning mentality, and existing rapport with the club only strengthen his case.
While a move to Celtic would represent his biggest managerial challenge to date, Keane's blend of experience, ambition and club affinity makes him a realistic contender.
Scottish Football at Free Bets
Stay right up to speed with Scottish Premiership betting here, with the latest odds, breaking news, and the best free bet offers all in one place.
From managerial changes and expert Scottish football tips to in-depth match previews and betting insights, we've got everything covered to help you stay informed and ahead of the game.
