Next Kilmarnock Manager Odds: Naismith Favourite to Replace McInnes
Looking for the latest next Kilmarnock manager odds?
With Derek McInnes moving to Hearts, betting sites have opened the market on who could take charge at Rugby Park next.
Ex-Killie player Steven Naismith heads the betting currently - here’s your complete guide to the leading names in the frame.
Next Kilmarnock Manager Odds
The football betting odds have Steven Naismith as the early favourite to take over at Kilmarnock following Derek McInnes’ departure.
Here’s a closer look at the leading contenders for the Rugby Park hot seat:
| Candidate | Odds (Next Kilmarnock Manager) |
|---|---|
| Steven Naismith | 4/6 |
| David Martindale | 3/1 |
| Stuart Kettlewell | 5/1 |
| John McGlynn | 10/1 |
These are hypothetical odds provided by industry experts
Steven Naismith
A former Kilmarnock player, Steven Naismith, is the early favourite to succeed Derek McInnes. The 38-year-old started his career at Rugby Park and retains strong ties to the club.
He recently managed Hearts, initially as interim boss before a permanent spell in 2023, and despite being dismissed after a poor run, his coaching credentials remain respected. Reports confirm Kilmarnock's plan to speak with Naismith, and bookmakers list him as an odds-on to take over.
His familiarity with the club, Scottish Premiership experience, and potential to include ex-teammate Chris Burke in his coaching setup make him a logical and sentimental frontrunner.
David Martindale
David Martindale has built a reputation as a resilient, pragmatic manager, most notably keeping Livingston competitive on a modest budget.
Despite Livi's 2024 relegation, Martindale's consistent top-six finishes in previous seasons highlight his tactical ability and leadership. The 49-year-old is admired across the league and would bring Premiership experience and a no-nonsense approach to Kilmarnock.
While he has no personal ties to the club, his track record fits the steady, proven operator profile. With McInnes gone, Martindale is seen as a credible alternative - bookmakers have him second-favourite - and media suggest he would be open to discussions after Livingston face Ross County in the play-offs.
Stuart Kettlewell
Stuart Kettlewell is a respected young manager with top-flight experience at Ross County and Motherwell.
He led Motherwell to a fifth-place finish before stepping down in 2025, citing personal reasons, despite leaving the club in a strong position. Kettlewell, 40, is known for his player development and tactical adaptability and is currently available.
Though he has no direct links to Kilmarnock, his recent success with a similarly resourced club makes him a logical candidate.
Bookmakers place him among the leading contenders, and his calm leadership style could offer continuity after McInnes. He's seen as a progressive yet realistic option.
John McGlynn
McGlynn is one of Scottish football's most experienced managers, currently in charge of Falkirk.
At 62, he offers a wealth of coaching knowledge and has managed Hearts and Raith Rovers. While not a glamour pick, McGlynn's steady approach and deep understanding of the Scottish game may appeal to Kilmarnock during a transitional phase.
He has no prior ties to the club but has been named in early betting markets. If Killie prioritise stability and know-how over risk, McGlynn could emerge as a dependable short-term solution.
Still, it would be a big call for him to leave newly-promoted Falkirk.
Scottish Premiership on Free Bets
Be sure to check back regularly as we cover all things Scottish Premiership betting in detail.
From managerial moves like this to breaking news, fresh odds, and weekly Scottish football tips from Kai Watson, we’ve got every angle covered
